Mastering the Christmas Turkey: Should You Roast or Brine for the Perfect Holiday Meal?

The Great Debate: Roast vs. Brine

As we dive into the heart of Christmas dinner preparations, you maybe asking yourself whether you should roast or brine your turkey? For many, the decision hinges on tradition and personal taste, but let’s break down the essentials to help you make the best choice for your festive feast.

Roasting is undoubtedly the more straightforward method, especially if you’ve invested in a premium turkey. With high-quality birds, it is not necessary to brine a turkey, as the natural flavours are already rich and robust. Roasting enhances these flavours, allowing the turkey’s inherent succulence to shine, complemented by the golden, crispy skin that everyone loves. The key here is to monitor your oven settings and timing carefully to avoid drying out the meat.

Bbrining is a technique that involves soaking the turkey in a saltwater mixture before cooking. This process not only seasons the bird throughout but also helps in moisture retention, ensuring a juicy result. For those who might not have access to a premium turkey, brining can elevate a less expensive bird to new heights of flavour and tenderness.

In the next section, we’ll provide a brief insight into each method, ensuring that you can execute either technique flawlessly for a memorable Christmas dinner. Then, we’ll compare the two to help you decide which option is best for your Christmas feast.

Step-by-Step Guide for Each Method

When deciding between roasting and brining your Christmas turkey, each method has its steps and tips to ensure you cook a tasty turkey for your guests.

**Roasting**: Begin by selecting a premium turkey, which is key as the quality greatly influences the flavour and texture. Preheat your oven to 160°C if you have a fan assisted oven. Prepare your turkey by patting the skin dry; this is crucial for achieving that desirable crispy finish. Season the bird lightly with salt, pepper, and perhaps some thyme or rosemary to complement its natural flavours. Add a red onion to the cavity.  Place it in a roasting tin breast side down, preferably on a bed of onions, carrots, and celery, which will add to the aroma and serve as a great base for gravy later. The general rule for cooking time is about 2hours and 10 minutes for a premium 5kg turkey. Remember to turkey the turkey on its back for the final 30 minutes to ensure that you brown the breast.  Manually skewer the thickest part of the thigh to ensure the juices run clear.  Leave the turkey to rest for at least 40 minutes.

**Brining**: If your turkey tends to end up more on the dry side, brining might be your go-to method. Dissolve salt in warm water (about 50 grams of salt per litre of water) and let it cool before submerging your turkey, ensuring it’s completely covered. Add aromatics like garlic, citrus slices, and herbs, which will subtly infuse the turkey with their flavours. Leave the turkey in this brine for 12 to 24 hours, depending on its size. Before roasting, remove the turkey from the brine, rinse it under cold water, and pat dry. Roast as you would a non-brined turkey, but remember, the brining process will impact the natural flavours slightly, making them milder yet potentially more moist and tender.

Comparison and Conclusion: Roasting vs. Brining, Which Wins the Christmas Dinner Crown?

When it comes to crowning the champion of Christmas dinner preparation methods, the decision between roasting and brining is a matter of personal taste and the desired outcome for your festive meal.

Roasting is often celebrated for its ability to enhance the natural, rich flavours of a premium turkey. If you’ve invested in a high-quality bird, roasting can be the perfect method to allow these flavours to stand out without the need for excess seasoning or moisture-enhancing techniques. The crispy skin and succulent meat that roasting provides is a testament to the simplicity and elegance of this cooking method. Furthermore, choosing to roast supports the argument that it is not necessary to brine a turkey if you have a premium one. The inherent quality and flavour of the turkey are enough to deliver a memorable meal, making roasting an excellent choice for those who appreciate the natural taste of their slow grown premium turkey.

On the other hand, brining has its own set of advantages, particularly for those who might not have access to a premium turkey or who have experienced dryness in their previous cooking endeavours. By soaking the turkey in a saltwater solution enhanced with herbs and spices, brining introduces additional moisture into the meat, ensuring that every slice is tender and juicy. This method can be particularly inviting for those who like their turkey meat to be uniformly moist and are willing to slightly adjust the natural flavours for a guaranteed juicy outcome.

The choice between roasting and brining ultimately boils down to what you value most for your Christmas dinner. If the priority is showcasing a premium turkey in its most natural and flavourful state, roasting is undoubtedly the way to go. The minimal preparation and focus on the turkey’s inherent qualities is extremely appealing.

Conversely, if you have purchased a more economical turkey, brining can help moisten and improve the texture of the bird. This method might mask some of the natural flavours of the turkey, but it compensates by offering a foolproof way to a moist, flavourful meal that can handle a variety of accompanying flavours and side dishes.

In conclusion, neither method holds an absolute advantage over the other; each has its unique strengths that cater to different culinary preferences and needs. Whether you choose the elegant simplicity of roasting or the moisture-assuring process of brining, both methods can lead to a delicious centerpiece for your Christmas feast. Thus, the winner of this debate truly depends on the chef’s goals: perfection in flavour or perfection in texture. Either way, your guests are in for a treat this Christmas.


Up Next:

Craig Michie

Based at Lochend of Barra, Inverurie, Craig Michie left a job as a town planner in 2009 and travelled around South America where he met his Columbian wife Maria. The couple returned to Scotland and the century-old family farm to create Barra Bronzes which was named winner in the ‘Judge’s Choice category, runner-up for ‘Best New Retail Product (businesses with up to 25 employees),’ and was named as highly commended in the ‘Best Young Business’ category at the Grampian Food Forum Innovation Awards 2016. In 2021, Craig won the UK Poultry Farmer of the Year award.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

christmas turkey order

Bronze Christmas Turkey


free range turkey crown

Bronze Turkey Crown


Barra Bronzes Sustainable Turkey

Sustainable Bird


Shopping Basket